17 Comments
User's avatar
Sasha Zavyalova's avatar

this was such a good read! i’d love read your thoughts on Byredo or Comme des Garçons Parfums

Expand full comment
Deepa Paul's avatar

So many descriptive joys in one piece! Savoring each one makes me feel like a child gleefully allowed to stomp in puddles on a rainy day. Brava!

Expand full comment
going steady's avatar

I know next to nothing about fragrance, but this is perhaps the push i need. An amazing read

Expand full comment
Joao's avatar

Such funny descriptions

Expand full comment
Madalynn Wilson's avatar

I've never been so engaged and entertained by a piece of writing as much as I was by this one. Please continue to do these in-depth brand analyses!!

Expand full comment
Rena's avatar

Would you consider ever reviewing Thé Matcha 26?

Expand full comment
MAKING SCENTS OF IT ALL's avatar

they don't move me either, I am glad they exhist, they opened a door to so many brands like my brand, but I don't ever crave to smell one, They are like a designer beef burger, all-American salt, sugar, fat rolled into one.

Expand full comment
Susan Ankersen's avatar

Superb! Haven’t canceled plans to finish an article in years or ever really. The pictures you paint with words are admirable.

Expand full comment
MAKING SCENTS OF IT ALL's avatar

loved this x

Expand full comment
Sumit's avatar

Simply dropping my heart on this post wouldn’t do justice to what I just read, but then no words I could possibly muster would either. Just accept my gratitude.

Expand full comment
Alexandra Goldstein's avatar

I don't think I've been so rapt over a long read in years. Simply beautiful in both content and style. Thank you!

Expand full comment
reelaesthete's avatar

Excellent piece. I sampled three times over ten years or so and never managed to fall for one of their scents. The closest I came was a 15ml of The Noir, and I never reached for it. I knew I was the target market, audience but I didn't get it. The shop is iconic enough that my husband even remembers me once entering one--and leaving empty handed. I knew they were aquired by Estée Lauder, so I imagined that might play some part. But reading this was so illuminating! I just felt light bulb after light bulb going off. I look forward to the rest of the series.

Expand full comment
Lordzoot's avatar

I never comment on blogs, but this was an absolutely superb piece. Well done! I'd love to read more long-form articles in this style. Perhaps you could do Penhaligon's sometime, as I find them an intruiging case study for criticism (and I say that as someone who has smelt/reviewed pretty much all of their catelogue and owns quite a few).

Consider me subscribed.

Expand full comment
nostream's avatar

Wonderful article, followed and looking forward to more.

Expand full comment
JN's avatar

Thank you for sharing- loved your article and agree with all the critiques. Ironically enough, le labo haunts me and I’m 5 candles deep and own 3 fragrances by them. Looking forward to your Frederic Malle review.

Expand full comment
J Beaudoin's avatar

Excellent article! I could read your posts on perfume all day :)

Expand full comment